Plain-English guide

Search competitors are not always your business competitors

The sites that beat you in Google and in AI answers may be directories, chains, blogs or training sites. Here is how to spot them and what to do.

Written and reviewed by Jon Goodey. Updated 16 November 2026.

The short answer

A search competitor is any website that shows up for the searches you want to be found for, whether or not it is a business rival. Directories, national chains, blogs and training sites often take the places you want, so it pays to look at who actually appears, not only at your trade rivals.

Working method

Who actually shows up

Look at the results, not at your list of rivals. 01 Search 02 Results 03 Note 04 Decide evidence review
Look at the results, not at your list of rivals.

Last checked: 16 November 2026.

What is a search competitor?

A search competitor is any website that shows up when people search for the things you want to be found for. In the Indexify SEO Platform they are found from the live Google results, the AI Overviews and the AI assistant answers for your main searches, not from a list of businesses in your trade.

So some will be your direct rivals and some will not. A directory, a national chain, a blog or a training site can all take the places you want. They may not be after your customers, but they are competing for the same searches. For search engines (SEO), and for being named or cited in AI answers (sometimes called AEO or GEO), they are the ones to get ahead of, whether or not you think of them as rivals. If those terms are new, SEO vs AEO vs GEO explains them.

Run a free check of your site

Free, one check per website. You get a private dashboard with three tasks written out in full. No card needed.

Why does it matter who beats me in search?

Your customer does not see your list of rivals. They see a results page and, increasingly, an AI answer. A citation is when an AI answer links to or names a website as its source. If a directory or a blog gets the citation, that is where the customer goes first, even if the directory sells nothing you sell.

Looking only at trade rivals can send you after the wrong sites. Looking at who actually appears tells you which pages and which questions to work on.

How do I find my search competitors by hand?

  1. Write down 3 to 5 searches a customer would type, such as "plumber in Leeds".
  2. Open a private window, so your own history does not shape the results.
  3. Search each one. Note every site in the first results, including directories and guides.
  4. If an AI answer appears, note which sites it links to or names. Note whether you are one of them.
  5. Repeat on another day. Results and AI answers change.
  6. Look for the sites that appear again and again. Those are your search competitors.

What should I do about each kind of search competitor?

KindWhat it isWhat to do
A directoryA listing site for your trade or areaBe listed, and make sure your details are accurate and match your website.
A national chainA big brand with many branchesAnswer local questions better: your area, your hours, your prices where you publish them, who does the work.
A blog or guideAn article that answers the questionAnswer that same question on your own page, clearly, near the top.
A training or advice siteA site teaching the subjectLink to it if it helps your reader, and write the page it does not: what you do, for whom, and what it costs.

When is a search competitor not worth chasing?

Not every site that appears deserves your time. Leave it alone when:

  • it answers a different question from the one your customer is asking;
  • it is a large publisher or encyclopaedia you cannot realistically answer better;
  • it appears for a search your customers would never use;
  • the only way to compete would be a page you would not be proud of.

Pick the few that take the places that matter most and that you can answer well on your own pages. Nobody can promise a position, so spend effort where a clearer page is genuinely yours to write.

How does the SEO Platform show my search competitors?

The Indexify SEO Platform lists search competitors in its dashboard, using the live Google results, AI Overviews and AI assistant answers for your main searches. In "Your focus" you can set up to 5 searches you want to be found for, add up to 3 sites you want compared with yours, and leave out up to 10 sites that are not relevant to you. The next weekly update uses your changes.

The search competitors block of the SEO Platform dashboard, with the explainer 'What is a search competitor?' open above a table of websites, the searches they appear for, and how many are shared with the site
Screenshot of the SEO Platform dashboard's search competitors block for indexify.co.uk, 16 November 2026.

It does not make the changes for you, and it is not built for agencies or many sites. For what to do with a result, see how to show up in Google AI Overviews and how to get your business mentioned by ChatGPT.

Run a free check of your site

Free, one check per website. You get a private dashboard with three tasks written out in full. No card needed.

Questions people ask

What is a search competitor?

A search competitor is any website that shows up for the searches you want to be found for, whether or not it is a business rival.

Are search competitors the same as my business competitors?

Not always. Some will be your direct rivals and some will not. A directory, a national chain, a blog or a training site can all take the places you want, even if they are not after your customers.

How do I find my search competitors for free?

Search your main searches in a private window and write down which sites show up. If there is an AI answer, note which sites it links to or names. Do it for 3 to 5 searches and look for the sites that repeat.

Should I try to beat every search competitor?

No. Leave out sites that are not relevant to you, such as a huge publisher whose page answers a different question from yours. Focus on the sites that take the places that matter to your customers and that you could realistically answer better.

Does the SEO Platform find my search competitors?

Yes. It finds them from the live Google results, the AI Overviews and the AI assistant answers for your main searches. In "Your focus" you can set up to 5 searches, up to 3 sites to compare with yours, and up to 10 sites to leave out.

Can I be sure that beating a search competitor will win me customers?

No. Search engines and AI tools decide what they show. Knowing who takes the places you want helps you decide what to write or fix, but it does not promise a position or a mention.

Jon Goodey discussing practical AI work with a team

A practical first conversation

Bring the work that is causing the problem.

Tell us what the team is trying to improve, what it has already tested and where confidence breaks down. We will suggest a proportionate next step.

Talk it through with Jon